Skip to main

The SEO versus Social Battle Has a New Winner

Authors: Jay Baer Jay Baer
Posted Under: Social Media
Listen to this Article

The SEO versus Social Battle Has a New Winner
Social media’s reign as a top source of referred, inbound traffic to websites may be over, according to new research from Shareaholic.
The most recent version of the rolling tracking study that measures traffic sources for more than 250,000 websites found a steep drop in visits from social media. Across more than 400 million visits, the top six search engines sent 34.8 percent of traffic. The top 13 social networks sent 25.6 percent of visitors.
seo vs social media traffic battle chart
Since 2014, search has lagged behind social, but the roles have clearly reversed, and there’s a new winner in the battle between SEO and social media as a traffic source.
For the first time in 3 years, search is responsible for more website traffic than social Click To Tweet

4 Reasons Why Search Is Back in the Lead versus Social Media

There are, of course, many intersecting trends and tweaks at play here, but these are the three primary reasons social is dipping and search is creeping upward.

1. Reduced Use of Social Overall

As I wrote about recently, Edison Research found that Americans are actually using social media LESS, especially Facebook. And given that Facebook is far and away the largest social network, a decline there is significant. (Read 6 Unexpected Trends in 2018 Social Media Research for more.)

2. De-prioritization of Companies and Organizations in Social Algorithms

Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter have all rolled out new algorithms in the past two years that fundamentally diminish exposure for company and organization content in favor of content published by individuals. This probably makes for a better, healthier stream of content, but it certainly impacts the number of clicks that social content can accrue to websites.
Shareaholic data shows a 25.8 percent drop in Facebook referred visits in one year. (I wrote about how to handle this in my article: 9 Antidotes to the Facebook Algorithm Squeeze.)
seo vs. social media traffic chart

3. Less Exposure for Posts Containing Links

Some of the algorithm adjustments in social media have given more reach to video content and, to some degree, photos. Simultaneously, the algorithm gives posts containing links less priority. This also has an impact on click-through traffic—so much so that our community management team at Convince & Convert is testing putting no links in social posts, but instead including links as the first comment.

4. Search Indexing More Social Content

Search engines are doing a much better job of indexing social media content right on their SERPs, making it possible for consumers to click through from search, instead of going to a social network and clicking through from there.
In the same period where Facebook referred traffic dropped 25 percent, visits coming from Google increased 21 percent.

Do Not Sleep on SEO

Smart marketers have paid attention to search throughout social’s rise, but this data clearly show that social’s days as the number one driver of traffic are at an end (and I don’t foresee them returning).
Google is certainly working hard to stay in front, as any decline in their ability to drive traffic is almost an existential issue for them, financially. It would be wise to follow their cue and re-prioritize search in your overall digital marketing plan.

Get Serious About Pinterest and Instagram

Facebook, despite its steep decline as a traffic source, is still the top social referrer. But notice the huge gains made by Pinterest? It’s now a clear number two in social and drives more traffic than every other non-Facebook social network combined. In fact, according to Shareaholic’s data, Pinterest is responsible for nearly half the traffic that Facebook delivers, and among a much smaller user base.
Instagram’s growth is skewed a bit due to the relatively recent addition of clickability on the platform. But the mobile photo/video platform is now tied with Twitter as a traffic source; a tremendous shift given that Instagram has historically been about “engagement” and Twitter has been thought of more as a traffic creator (in addition to its role in conversations and customer service).

Is LinkedIn Next?

Certainly, LinkedIn focuses on its business audience, which makes it relevant to only a subset of the population. But the newfound emphasis on content on Linkedin makes me wonder if it will see a spike in its referred traffic in the next report, similar to what Instagram experienced in this study.
For my own interactions, and the content we create here at Convince & Convert, we are putting more effort into Linkedin than ever before, pulling resources away from Facebook.
This report fascinates me because it is VERY rare in business, technology, and marketing for a lost lead to be regained. Apple was nearly dead as a computer maker and was then resurrected. But Apple has never outsold Windows PCs. Once Chrome took over as the dominant web browser, Internet Explorer didn’t rally back and pull in front again.
What we’re witnessing currently in the fight between SEO and social media for website traffic referral preeminence is nearly unprecedented, and it should make you reconsider how you’re allocating your resources across the full sweep of your digital marketing.
If we can help, let me know.

Article Banner Image

Get our best tips. Join the smartest marketers who receive our twice monthly update.

hbspt.forms.create({ region: "na1", portalId: "5496414", formId: "d63cbd99-2e09-4bfd-94fe-0f625085f91a" });

Join the Social Pros LinkedIn Community

Join a community of real social pros doing social media on LinkedIn. Receive all the inspiration and ideas straight to your feed and add your thoughts to the conversation.

Follow Social Pros on LinkedIn

Subscribe to Social Pros Podcast

b2b influencer

Ready to Get Started?

I am looking for...