Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook?

Today’s post is a collaboration with Clinton Bonner, community connectivity expert, futurist, and blogger at Everything to Everything.

Starbucks is not only offering free Wi-Fi in all stores come this fall, but also unveiling their Starbucks Digital Network that all in-store web and mobile users will have the opportunity to enjoy (it’s a partnership with Yahoo!). Why would Starbucks need their own digital network? What impact could Starbucks’ brand of wireless connectivity have on consumer behavior? Plenty.

starbucks digital network Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook?Imagine a customer-only network chock full of ‘In Network’ freebies that you can ONLY get while on ‘location’ (in this case at a Starbucks). Free access to premium news sites such as the New York Times and Wall Street Journal, free iTunes downloads, and for the kids free access to Nick Jr. games that typically require monthly fees.

Does this change how you might browse the Web, with your physical ‘branded’ location determining how and how much you pay for premium online content? Does this change where you might go to get your next cup of coffee and how you come to discover music and other consumer products?

Working Together to Remove Money From Your Pocket

What used to be content intended for all end-users to access the same way is now possibly just a piece of the marketing puzzle to properly equip cross-brand, cross-vertical collaboration and integration. What was once ‘the end’ purchase: a physical newspaper, a cup of coffee, or a digital song download is now a key cog in the greater scheme of getting the consumer to fork over more dollars, more consistently. Here’s a post from Clinton all about the band No Doubt and their successful shifting of the meaning of ‘end content’.

In the Starbucks case, it’s even more powerful. The consumer might frequent the Starbucks more, spend more money and/or time, or might really enjoy having full access to USA Today and become a converted, paid member. All of this marketing and purchase value is delivered under the cloak of giving you a new, richer experience. And it does indeed, which is why it’s so powerful. We’re willing accomplices in our own marketing funnel.

What’s Next (Potentially)?

Imagine a Starbucks patron is reading a review in the free version of the New York Times about a Chardonnay and suddenly their iPhone buzzes. A text coupon arrives in your mobile inbox and you are offered $5 off a wine purchase of $20 or more from a local wine purveyor. The coupon has a timed code and expires in 3 days, nudging you to act. The era of the hyper-relevant advertisement is upon us. And that example is just scratching the surface.

The means to deliver the right branded message, via the most influential medium, in the exact right moment is coming VERY soon. Starbucks could use their SDN to reinvent themselves as a key member of any local community, and not as a coffeehouse, but as the best-possible advertising platform available in every city and town in the country. Because of the commerce potential (subscriptions, coupons) a Starbucks local ad network (possibly empowered by Yahoo’s sales force) might even be a revenue share, making it even more efficient for marketers than Google Adwords or Facebook ads.

It’s capitalism and marketing at its most brilliant. Unapologetic intrusiveness, warmly invited by the customer because the perceived value is high.

If you were Starbucks, how would you take advantage of this new network?

pf button both Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook?
Genesis Theme Framework

Convince & Convert Runs on the Genesis Framework

The Genesis Framework, which powers this site, offers a huge selection of amazing designs which can change the way your site looks. They are easy to customize and include layout options as well as custom widgets, so get Genesis now!

Order The NOW Revolution

Social media and technology have changed business forever.

Buy Now
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Starbucks Digital NetworkYahoo!New York TimesWSJ http://bit.ly/dc9IbO http://bit.ly/boxI6U

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook?: Todays post is a collaboration wi... #marketing http://bit.ly/bgjEjA

RT @greggvm: #LocationBased social networks w/value. :) "Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook?" http://j.mp/9jJ4aT #LBS

Rt @jaybaer Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook?: Todays post is a collaboration with Clinton ... http://bit.ly/941X05

RT @jaybaer: Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook?: Todays post is a collaboration wi... http://bit.ly/cX1ZlH #marketing

A fascinating piece. The deployment possibilities are endless.

The one advantage that Facebook has over the Starbucks network (admirably extrapolated in the post) is that in a recession-addled world, #fb is free, and not geographically limited in scope. However, I do agree with the general thrust of the post that the idea clearly has potential to sell more stuff.

Interesting post - and great signal-to-noise ratio in the comments!

I have to say that I was initially interpreting your perspective as a negative one, perhaps misinterpreting your references to "unapologetic intrusiveness" and "willing accomplices in our own marketing funnel". In one of your replies to another comment, I see you also say "There is a tipping point when an interruption becomes a welcome knock and the era of hyper relevancy will get us there. Starbucks will do this cautiously and correctly." So I guess you see the Starbucks Digital Network as a positive development.

I recently wrote a related post after watching a video of Howard Schultz at TheGrill media and entertainment conference, immediately after watching Steven Johnson wax poetic about the innovative culture of "liquid networks" in coffeehouses during his most recent TED Talk. In the post, The Starbucks Digital Network, Engagement, Enlightenment and Third Places, I raise questions about the costs of greater online engagement, especially to the probable diminishment of offline engagement and serendipitous connections that Schultz used to espouse in his advocacy of Starbucks as a third place.

I have no doubt that Starbucks and its partners will profit handsomely from their unapologetic intrusions, but as a proponent of third places, and the conversations and community they promote, I am disillusioned with this latest announcement. Based on other comments on this post, including your own, I suspect this is a perspective not widely shared here.

Ultimately, though, the "cafe society" was about the caffeine. ;-)

Wow, that's totally true. That's an entirely different business model for Starbucks and potentially many more companies. I bet many more companies will start creating partnerships to advertise each other's companies at the right time/right place.

The idea is awesome, unfortunately I hate Starbucks coffee but love Facebook! :)

A little Grooveshark, a little Groupon. And a splash of re-targeting. H'mmmm. Will users be able to log into the network when they're not at Starbucks because, believe it or not, some people can't work all day in coffee houses (though I love how the one in town is always playing Sam Cooke).

If they can tie it in with a killer content sharing network and, even better, an app, then Facebook would have issues.

And Yahoo!? So, is that Bing instead?

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to #Facebook? - http://om.ly/sJnI

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://bit.ly/cvkpne by @ClintonBon. (via @LindsayFultz & @DaveKerpen)

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? Interesting thinking on Convince & Convert http://ow.ly/2uXNy

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? - http://bit.ly/9ohmad

Interesting blog - Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://bit.ly/9DzzXJ

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? by @jaybaer http://ow.ly/2vJR4

RT @MarketingUoC: Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? - http://bit.ly/9ohmad

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? - http://bit.ly/9ohmad

cc @cristiangbr RT @adrianchira: Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to #Facebook? - http://om.ly/sIAh

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to #Facebook? - http://om.ly/sIAh

RT @jaybaer: Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://bit.ly/9ohmad

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://bit.ly/9ohmad #socialmedia #smo #sm http://goo.gl/fb/gOSge

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://bit.ly/9ohmad #socialmedia #smo #sm

RT @DaveKerpen: Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? - http://bit.ly/9ohmad (really interesting frm @ClintonBon)

RT @jaybaer: Why Starbucks Might Become the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook http://bit.ly/9ohmad

RT @jaybaer: Why Starbucks Might Become the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook http://bit.ly/9ohmad

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://t.co/ppCOfB3

RT @LBSchat: Q3 How can Starbucks new content delivery network leverage location platforms? http://ow.ly/2uVOn #LBSchat #LBSchat

Q3 How can Starbucks' new content delivery network leverage location platforms? http://ow.ly/2uVOn #LBSchat #LBSchat

@bcfrawley No doubt. A completely custom online experience while you're at the location ALL ABOUT THEM. Great concept! http://ow.ly/2vtPv

RT @jaybaer: Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://bit.ly/9ohmad

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to #Facebook? - http://om.ly/sGZW

RT @Addiply: V v intersting @HarryHarrold @MattWaring @AndyBaker1 http://bit.ly/9B0FY0 Anything they can do, we can... lol http://bit.ly ...

Starbucks is looking to take a share in the online advertising market by creating a digital network for its US stores: http://ow.ly/2v2Tf

This is brilliant: Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://bit.ly/9ohmad

Facebook Competitor...Starbucks?? http://bit.ly/du5NR8

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? - http://bit.ly/9ohmad

RT @johnfoleyjr: Why would Starbucks be Facebook's most dangerous competitor? http://ilnk.me/406f

Why would Starbucks be Facebook's most dangerous competitor? http://ilnk.me/406f

RT @JeffHurt Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? by @clintonbon http://ow.ly/2veZk

Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? by @clintonbon http://ow.ly/2veZk

RT @Addiply: V v intersting @HarryHarrold @MattWaring @AndyBaker1 http://bit.ly/9B0FY0 Anything they can do, we can... http://bit.ly/bKKp8a

V v intersting @HarryHarrold @MattWaring @AndyBaker1 http://bit.ly/9B0FY0 Anything they can do, we can... lol http://bit.ly/bKKp8a

RT @cosmond: Starbucks taking online communities to next level: http://bit.ly/9B0FY0 @DrewEllis Fascinating ain't it? http://bit.ly/bKKp8a

RT @cosmond: Starbucks taking online communities to the next level: http://bit.ly/9B0FY0

From @JayBear Is Starbucks the Most Dangerous Competitor to Facebook? http://bit.ly/9ohmad <= SBUX rec's increm. rev from subs, coupons

Starbucks Network? More tired than wired; http://ow.ly/2uKlJ

Interesting idea, I like what @robertwheatley added, thanks for sharing!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] Visit link: Convince and Convert Blog: Social Media Strategy and Social Media … [...]

  2. [...] lives.  Marketing will become more personal and hyper-targeted. Jay used an example by pointing to the new Starbucks digital network with Yahoo where you will soon be able to get free access to subscription content such as [...]

  3. [...] Starbucks Digital Network to Come this Fall On August 26, 2010, Guest Post wrote: TweetHaving read Jay Baer’s blog post about the Starbucks Digital Network to come to all stores this fall, I became quite impressed with [...]