Take Off the Social Media Blindfold

Among the many exceptionally interesting data snacks in the recent MarketingProfs’ State of Social Media report is one showing that businesses of all sizes and types are primarily using Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin, YouTube, and blogging.

And while it’s on one hand a positive that we’re stating to see some norms and best practices emerge within social media, it’s a tremendous mistake to restrict your social media activities to just the “Big Five.”

hiddenface 300x199 Take Off the Social Media BlindfoldThere are literally hundreds of other places your customers could be talking about your brand within the social Web, and it’s imperative that you hear all of them. If a subset (even a small one) of your customer base loves Tripadvisor, or Yelp, or FriendFeed, or their Ning group or whatever, that does not make them less important to your brand’s perception than people on Twitter or Facebook, it just makes them a different segment of your audience.

Remember, there is a REASON they spend their time within the social ecosystem on Yelp and not Facebook – because that’s the community they PREFER. And in fact, people that make choices that are less conventional tend to defend those choices more passionately than the “me too” crowd. And, because there are fewer total users, the opinions of any individual are magnified.

Further, regardless of where the content is posted, it will be found and indexed by search engines, becoming part of your brand’s permanent record, like that crappy tattoo of a hummingbird you got in Cancun.

Dear Marriott: Pay Attention

Consider this horrifying example for Marriott. I did a quick check of Google Sidewiki (a plug-in for Firefox and Internet Explorer that lets you comment on Web pages, and those comments are “stuck” the Web page like a Post-It note). I found this solitary post, ripping Marriott for not removing this guy from their email newsletter list. I’m not sure what’s worse, the company not paying attention to secondary and tertiary layers of the social Web and thus not finding this, or knowing about it and not leaving a reply. Either way, their silence is deafening.

Google Sidewiki.jpg Take Off the Social Media Blindfold

Do millions of people use Sidewiki? Not yet, but since it’s a Google project, there’s a fair chance it will take off. And for the people that are already using Sidewiki, doesn’t this impact how you perceive Marriott? And now I’ve shared it with all of you, so a comment on a “minor” social outpost continues to fester, unabated.

I realize it’s a hassle to monitor your brand across all of these places. It takes time. Time you probably don’t have. But you know how municipal police forces crush graffiti problems? They paint over it immediately, wherever it occurs. It’s a lesson that applies equally in social media.

The days of “if we answer back, it just gives them credence” are over. Take off the blinders, remove the earplugs, and defend yourself.

(disclaimer: MarketingProfs is a Convince & Convert client. You might want to read another post that references their data: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media)

(for more on Google Sidewiki, read this excellent post by Jeremiah Owyang)

pf button both Take Off the Social Media Blindfold
Genesis Theme Framework

Convince & Convert Runs on the Genesis Framework

The Genesis Framework, which powers this site, offers a huge selection of amazing designs which can change the way your site looks. They are easy to customize and include layout options as well as custom widgets, so get Genesis now!

Order The NOW Revolution

Social media and technology have changed business forever.

Buy Now
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

What is the ROI on spending time on the one-percent? I'd prefer to cover 90% of the audience excellently rather that 98% 'averagely'.

RT @jaybaer: Take Off the Social Media Blindfold http://bit.ly/aEHgqP

Thnx! RT @bullseyevideo: Take Off the Social Media Blindfold - Convince & Convert http://ow.ly/11pSH #eduweb #highered

RT @bullseyevideo: Take Off the Social Media Blindfold - Convince & Convert http://ow.ly/11pTX #fb

RT @bullseyevideo: Take Off the Social Media Blindfold - Convince & Convert http://ow.ly/11pTX #fb

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold - Convince & Convert http://ow.ly/11pTX #fb

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold | social crm | Social Media Consulting - Convince & Convert http://bit.ly/cfNGAj

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold | social crm | Social Media Consulting - Convince & Convert http://bit.ly/cJzbqQ

Interesting post by @jaybaer - "Take Off the Social Media Blindfold" http://bit.ly/9ampZy - good advise on reaching more social networks

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold - http://bit.ly/axs017

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold http://tinyurl.com/ygnbc8a) via @jaybaer a must read !

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold | social crm | Social Media Consulting - Convince & Convert http://ow.ly/12FQl

checking out: RT @BrennaElise: Reading: Take Off the Social Media Blindfold http://bit.ly/cIBjyc

Reading: Take Off the Social Media Blindfold http://bit.ly/cIBjyc

Jay -while I couldn't agree with you more we have to get people up and running first. Most of my clients are traditional manufacturers and are scared to death of anything associated with social. Once we get them up and running on the basics( your top 5) we can then start them utilizing the other tools available. As usual good stuff

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold! http://bit.ly/aL4FND

Twitter Comment

RT @jaybaer A great article that doesn't let you forget other social media, esp #sidewiki [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

RT @jaybaer A great article that doesn't let you forget other social media, esp #sidewiki [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Thanks Marcel. I appreciate you weighing in - and very quickly, too. You must be listening! ;)

Hi Barb and Jay,

Jay - you are right, Radian6 can track sidewiki content for your web properties (or any web sites you care to track sidewiki content).

Barb - that is what we do... our software constantly monitors all the niche places (and popular places too) to bring all the conversations that you care about into your "1-800" number, to use the analogy. This way you can spend your time in analysis and engagement/conversation rather than worry about looking under every sofa cushion... and there are many.

Cheers,@lebrun
Marcel LeBrun
CEO, Radian6

PS - Jay... love the comment: "The days of 'if we answer back, it just gives them credence' are over." Amen!

Maybe he deleted it b/c he's embarrassed that his whiny post became a part of the public discourse. :)

Someone must have appeased him offline, because the Sidewiki post is gone, and I don't think you can unilaterally delete them unless you are the author. Hmmm.

We actually agree for the most part, Janet. Just note that I specified that replies should include "we're looking into it" if and only if the company is actually looking into it.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't necessarily agree that every single complaint deserves a detailed explanation of the problem, nor the promise of a resolution. This guy just seems like a whiner with an axe to grind...and obviously doesn't know how to block a sender in his email client. Might be a different story if there were 3 other people that responded to him in agreement...

Other than "Thank you for your feedback - ping me via @whatever on Twitter if you'd like to discuss.", what can Marriot say to appease him? Will the agent that responds have any influence over the email marketing process? Probably not. More likely that they'll pass along the complaint to someone else, which precludes a detailed explanation/resolution. (I'm not saying that this is the ideal process, by the way. Just the reality.)

Seems to me that social media damage control should be about more than just squishing ants.

Absolutely. The other benefit is that social media puts marketing and customer service on the same team, and that's a long-term corporate advantage, in my estimation.

Bingo. People have been talking shit about your company since you opened the doors. Social media is an opportunity to now put a magnifying glass on some of that, whereas previously you never would have known about it. Social media doesn't create problems with your brand, it finds them.

Thanks so much for the fantastic comment, Barb. Really smart thinking. I am not sure on this, but I believe that Radian6 (and perhaps other software) is monitoring Sidewiki content. But, I'm not positive. You would certainly think that Google Alerts would catch it, since it's a Google product, but perhaps not. In that regard, maybe Sidewiki is a bad example. Maybe TripAdvisor or Yelp fits the social phone analogy better, since that content is indexed, RSS-able, etc.

I agree with DJ. You can have junior staff listen (or operate listening software). But response with appropriate tonality is not a freelance gig.

Totally depends on your audience. If you were localized biz, I'd guess Yelp. If you were B2B, I'd say Linkedin. If you were travel, I'd say TripAdvisor. If you listen broadly enough, you should be able to find the right places where you're being discussed.

There's certainly a lot of that going around. Travel/tourism especially is prone to review stuffing, either false positives, or false negatives against competitors. I'm very interested to see how the new Yelp version and FourSquare and Gowalla help fix that. You'll be able to tell if the reviewer has actually visited the location, how frequently, and how recently. Viva GPS.

Twitter Comment

RT @jaybaer Take off the social media blindfold [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Eric, I tend to disagree with you regarding how any company should handle negative comments. The issues should always be addressed, explained and, if appropriate, resolved by the company in order to prove their integrity. Your simple reply of "thank you, we are looking into it" is not a solution. The problem should be explained in detail, including the resolution; and then, the comment needs to be buried in the search engines by the company getting positive information out there. Just my 2-cents.

Twitter Comment

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

RT @jaybaer Take off the social media blindfold [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

In an ideal situation, focusing on all areas where your consumers are talking about your brand would be great! Although, even for social media managers or consultants managing social media full time, it is difficult to focus on so many areas - to do that, you would really need a team of 5 or 6 people just spending time all day scanning the internet. Then you would need some more people to handle the engagement and analytics - which can get expensive. It's just better to focus your time on the most popular social media networks where the majority of your consumers are. Even in traditional marketing, it's impossible to reach all of your customers - it's the same in social media.

Twitter Comment

Words of wisdom from @jaybaer: Take Off the Social Media Blindfold [link to post])

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

"Take off the Social Media Blindfold", interesting read via @jaybear [link to post] That's why we recommend buzz monitoring to clients.

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

Words of wisdom from @jaybaer: Take Off the Social Media Blindfold [link to post])

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Nice article. When it comes to social media there is a cultural and corporate shift that is taking place in the world. The corporate world started to push past awareness and into action. As this transition takes hold, companies are evolving from their reactive states, and moving toward more proactive approaches in protecting themselves in social media through proper advice and training and development. Social media has begun to play a key role in how companies shape their corporate policies and present themselves as good corporate citizens starting from the top of the pyramid.

Twitter Comment

"Take off the Social Media Blindfold", interesting read via @jaybear [link to post] That's why we recommend buzz monitoring to clients.

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

Great post from @jaybaer [link to post] expand your listening capabilities with sidewiki but above all, listen to your customers

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Thanks for the great post Jay. As always, very informative. Love the Google Sidewiki story. Its amazing that I am still trying to convince clients that they cannot ignore or control social media and what people are saying about their brand online. So many still feel like they shouldn't 'open that can' because it will mean 'people are going to talk negatively about you'. They already are!! You cannot stop them! BUT at least you can be part of the conversation!
Thanks again Jay -
Lucinda Callie
twitter.com/lcallie
twitter.com/sumo_group
www.sumo.com.au

Eric:

I've had that discussion before about paying college students or an intern to manage this stuff. I'm all for them helping to triage, but this gig is not a $10/hr job, IMHO.

DJ Waldow@djwaldow
Director of Community, Blue Sky Factory

Twitter Comment

Take Off the Social Media Blindfold, by Jay Baer - [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

I think that is the real key. Most companies are just getting started. They need to be proactive with FB and Twitter and , as Jay said, monitor the situation on others.

If you had to pick one or two beside FB or Twitter, which would you suggest.

Thanks.

...or just paying college students $10/hour to find negative complaints and offset them with positive endorsements.

Twitter Comment

Great post from @jaybaer [link to post] expand your listening capabilities with sidewiki but above all, listen to your customers

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Jay -

"Either way, their silence is deafening." Love it.

As with Eric Boggs, I also and back and forth on this. ("Disclaimer" - Eric is a good buddy of mine. I worked with him for years while at Bronto). I still struggle with answering EVERYTHING. I think the next evolution of this is having your community respond for you. I'm starting to see that more and more. If you can grown your community into rabid fans who will not only evangelize for you and help with marketing, but they will also come to your defense. That's the bees knees, right?

DJ Waldow@djwaldow
Director of Community, Blue Sky Factory

Thanks for responding.

I checked out your other blog and appreciate it. Of all the people talking out there about social media (that I have observed, anyway), you seem to be the most level-headed. Just like there is good and bad advertising, there's good and bad social media. Because we're arguably in the infancy of social media (though much of the underpinnings of social media have been around forever, just not on the internet), it seems like anything social media today is deemed great, right and something everyone should do. We're still learning.

Keep up the good work and us on the right track, Jay.

tp