Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media

In nearly every speech or Webinar I conduct, someone in the audience asks “But all this social media stuff doesn’t apply to B2B right?”

Yes, social media applies to B2B. In fact, social media can be MORE transformative for a B2B company than a B2C company. This is because B2B has a smaller potential customer base, a higher average price point, and a customer decision funnel that is more influenced by word of mouth and reputation. Turning your customers into advocates and marketers on behalf of your brand pays off a lot more when you’re selling $10,000 pieces of manufacturing equipment, than it does when you’re selling $3 cans of Pringles.

Are there differences between B2B and B2C social media campaigns? Of course. But those differences are at the tactics layer, not the strategy layer. Creating and calibrating a social media strategy for any company should follow the same process. You need to determine why your company should be social, for whom your efforts are intended and where your audience is in the buying cycle, and how you’ll measure success. None of that is impacted in the slightest by whether you’re selling to consumers or other businesses.

I’ve asserted that B2B social media tactics vary from B2C, in that they are typically rooted in consumer education and thought leadership, and thus require deeper layers of interaction. Private brand communities vs. Facebook. Linkedin Groups vs. Twitter. Podcasts vs. YouTube.

Two Sides of the Same Coin

state of social media marketing Crushing the Myth of B2B Social MediaA remarkable recent study by MarketingProfs, however, pokes a hole in even that notion of B2B and B2C social media divergence. (disclosure: MarketingProfs is a client)

Their State of Social Media Marketing report – a comprehensive survey of more than 5,000 marketers – is filled with more than 225 charts and graphs about all things social media. I believe it to be the most complete picture yet painted of how marketers are thinking about and deploying social media. (Report is $359 if you’re a MarketingProfs member, and if you’re a data hound you can roll around in it for days).

MProfs TSoSMM report D6ITO page 84 of 242 300x250 Crushing the Myth of B2B Social MediaAccording to this report, even with regard to social media execution, B2B and B2C are much more aligned than conventional wisdom suggests. This chart shows usage of five major social outposts by organization type. The statistical similarity shocks me. The range of Facebook usage is just 37% – 51%. Twitter is even narrower at 36% – 46%. The pattern holds for YouTube and Linkedin, too.

What this means is that in reality, B2C and B2B social media marketers are largely using the same social tactics. The differences may then lie in use cases and expectations. The variation may come in how social media is used, not which social media are used.

Size Doesn’t Matter

I’m also often asked about how B2B social media execution differs between large and small companies. The difference is actually very small, as the goal of social media is to make big companies act like small ones.

MProfs TSoSMM report D6ITO page 86 of 242 300x219 Crushing the Myth of B2B Social MediaThe MarketingProfs research bears this out, as usage of primary social outposts is almost identical, regardless of budget. Whether you’re spending millions per year on marketing, or less than $50,000, your proclivity toward being active on Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin and YouTube is strikingly similar.

Focus on How, Not What

I draw two conclusions from this data.

First, marketers of all stripes seem to have accepted (for now) that social media in large measure = Facebook, Twitter, Linkedin, YouTube and blogs. This is a bit disheartening and dangerous, as social media is and can be a lot more than just your company’s presence on these sites. It’s this focus on “media” rather than “social” that could doom this industry eventually.

Second, can we please stop all this silly haranguing about B2B vs. B2C in social media? Strategically it’s the same, and at least for now it appears that tactical similarities are also universal.

Can you think of an important difference between B2C and B2B social media ? For more on this topic, check out this excellent post from the always-on Amber Naslund: Social Media for B2B, and a killer treatise from CK Kerley about B2B vs. B2C – “It’s the Engagement Level, Stupid.”

pf button both Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media
Genesis Theme Framework

Convince & Convert Runs on the Genesis Framework

The Genesis Framework, which powers this site, offers a huge selection of amazing designs which can change the way your site looks. They are easy to customize and include layout options as well as custom widgets, so get Genesis now!

Order The NOW Revolution

Social media and technology have changed business forever.

Buy Now
Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

B2B Social Media - Size Doesnt Matter http://bit.ly/4zGXfv #bb

"Turning your customers into advocates and marketers on behalf of your brand pays off a lot more when youre selling $10,000 pieces of manufacturing equipment, than it does when youre selling $3 cans of Pringles."

Jay, I love what you said here... The dynamics surrounding the use of social media are very similar in a B2C or B2B setting. Great post!

There is a Third Focus: Value. Yours, and all Publishers, value of content.

One good New Years Resolution is to join other bloggers and take a step towards transparency from the companies who profit from your blog writing by NOT writing April 15, 2010.

Let private companies like Lijit and public ones like Google know: you know they have not been transparent about what they make from our blogs; what % they share with US, the people creating the content they use and re-sell at great profit.

If you cant keep your fingers from working on April 15th, 2010, then ask companies like Lijit, Google, or any other currently profiting from you blog this basic question:

What do you make from my work? What % are you sharing with me?

Your UNION, P.U.B., Publishers Union of Bloggers, has asked these simple questions from companies such as Lijit and Google, and they have either not answered (Google) or used personal attacks and threatened legal action against P.U.B. and its members (Lijit).

Why? Google, Lijit, and others profiting from publishers plan on there being no power among independent, freethinking writers. 'They will never act as a group, never ask us to be transparent, we can pay them whatever we want, if anything'

Is your creative work worth asking this simple question?
Then ask it, April 15th, 2010, and tell your publishing peers to ask for it too.

Keep up spreading the love,

Barney

Barney Moran
Founder, P.U.B.

There is a third focus beyond media and social: Value. How do the companies that request publishers allow them to latch onto and resell their work, value the publishers and this content?

One good New Years Resolution is to join other bloggers and take a step towards transparency from the companies who profit from your blog writing by NOT writing April 15, 2010.

Let private companies like Lijit and public ones like Google know: you know they have not been transparent about what they make from our blogs; what % they share with US, the people creating the content they use and re-sell at great profit.

If you cant keep your fingers from working on April 15th, 2010, then ask companies like Lijit, Google, or any other currently profiting from you blog this basic question:

What do you make from my work? What % are you sharing with me?

Your UNION, P.U.B., Publishers Union of Bloggers, has asked these simple questions from companies such as Lijit and Google, and they have either not answered (Google) or used personal attacks and threatened legal action against P.U.B. and its members (Lijit).

Why? Google, Lijit, and others profiting from publishers plan on there being no power among independent, freethinking writers. 'They will never act as a group, never ask us to be transparent, we can pay them whatever we want, if anything'

Is your creative work worth asking this simple question?
Then ask it, April 15th, 2010, and tell your publishing peers to ask for it too.

Keep up spreading the knowledge, and remember the third focus, our individual value, whether the top, or the bottom, of the barrel.

Barney

Barney Moran
Founder, P.U.B.

Not sure I agree that B2C and B2B social media are similar. If you mean social media marketing than you're probably right. Yet social media is and will be used in more disciplines than marketing and branding.

Companies are using social media to complete projects and find subject matter experts. Crowd Sourcing and Collaboration are starting to leverage social media in new and innovative ways.

So outside of marketing, and since the goals of B2B and B2C social media are different I suspect the strategy needs to be as well.
.-= Mark Fidelman´s last blog ..Larry Hawes and the Challenges of Implementing Enterprise 2.0 in Todays Corporations =-.

Not sure I agree that B2C and B2B social media are similar. If you mean social media marketing than you're probably right. Yet social media is and will be used in more disciplines than marketing and branding.

Companies are using social media to complete projects and find subject matter experts. Crowd Sourcing and Collaboration are starting to leverage social media in new and innovative ways.

So outside of marketing, and since the goals of B2B and B2C social media are different I suspect the strategy needs to be as well.
.-= Mark Fidelman´s last blog ..Larry Hawes and the Challenges of Implementing Enterprise 2.0 in Todays Corporations =-.

Jay, I enjoyed your post about this important research about the adoption and use of social media as a marketing channel.

Social media certainly is playing a big role in B2B marketing. However, I am still seeing only anecdotal evidence that social media is good for B2B lead generation.

By lead generation, Im not talking about clicks, visits or even subscriptions. Im talking about qualified, sales-ready leads.

If you (or any of your readers) have any quantifiable evidence of social medias role in generating qualified, sales-ready B2B leads, I sure would like to see it.

Sincerely,
Mac McIntosh
mcintosh@sales-lead-experts.com

Jay, I enjoyed your post about this important research about the adoption and use of social media as a marketing channel.

Social media certainly is playing a big role in B2B marketing. However, I am still seeing only anecdotal evidence that social media is good for B2B lead generation.

By lead generation, Im not talking about clicks, visits or even subscriptions. Im talking about qualified, sales-ready leads.

If you (or any of your readers) have any quantifiable evidence of social medias role in generating qualified, sales-ready B2B leads, I sure would like to see it.

Sincerely,
Mac McIntosh
mcintosh@sales-lead-experts.com

Twitter Comment

Focus on How, Not WhatRT @IHayato: B2B [link to post] - Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

RT @IHayato B2B [link to post] - Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

RT @IHayato: B2B [link to post] - Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

B2B [link to post] - Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

According to @jaybaer "Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media [link to post] " - B2B vs. B2C in social media strategically its the same - Posted using Chat Catcher

Jay - a truly great post indeed. Glad someone's taken the time to clarify this point because there are a lot of small, b2b companies sitting on the sidelines wondering where they fit.

How do we feel about scaling social media in the b2b setting? Obviously, it's easier when we're talking about a smaller organization, but there are some massive b2b companies out there. Does the scaling problem still exist whether it's b2c or b2b? My initial thought was that an individual within a b2b organization could make as much of a measurable impact, if not more maybe, than if XYZ b2b corp was engaged as an enterprise. Just a thought...

hope you are having a great holiday season.
.-= Chuck Hemann´s last blog ..Case Studies Shouldnt Be The Basis Of Your Social Media Program =-.

Twitter Comment

Focus on How, Not WhatRT @IHayato: B2B [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

FriendFeed Comment

"Its... [link to post] - Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

"Its this focus on media rather than social that could doom this industry eventually." {disagree, media=biz,... [link to post] - Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

RT @IHayato B2B [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

RT @IHayato: B2B [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

B2B [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

According to @jaybaer "Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media [link to post] " - B2B vs. B2C in social media strategically its the same

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Jay - a truly great post indeed. Glad someone's taken the time to clarify this point because there are a lot of small, b2b companies sitting on the sidelines wondering where they fit.

How do we feel about scaling social media in the b2b setting? Obviously, it's easier when we're talking about a smaller organization, but there are some massive b2b companies out there. Does the scaling problem still exist whether it's b2c or b2b? My initial thought was that an individual within a b2b organization could make as much of a measurable impact, if not more maybe, than if XYZ b2b corp was engaged as an enterprise. Just a thought...

hope you are having a great holiday season.
.-= Chuck Hemann´s last blog ..Case Studies Shouldnt Be The Basis Of Your Social Media Program =-.

FriendFeed Comment

"Its... [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Twitter Comment

"Its this focus on media rather than social that could doom this industry eventually." {disagree, media=biz,... [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Jay,

Excellent piece - really. I love this quote

You just summed up the problem today in so very few, quality words. You will see in 2010 that most companies will, hopefully, leave behind both notions (media is important, and B2C and B2C are different) due to results that we will start seeing in the market.

It is the natural progression in the market, and the signs are already showing up that we are approaching the climb up towards the "plateau of productivity" as Gartner calls it. This is when it starts to be fun.

Nicely said,
Esteban
.-= Esteban Kolsky´s last blog ..Things I Dont Want to Hear Anymore in 2010 =-.

Twitter Comment

love this quote "Its this focus on media rather than social that could doom this industry eventually" from @jaybaer [link to post] - Posted using Chat Catcher

Jay,

Excellent piece - really. I love this quote

You just summed up the problem today in so very few, quality words. You will see in 2010 that most companies will, hopefully, leave behind both notions (media is important, and B2C and B2C are different) due to results that we will start seeing in the market.

It is the natural progression in the market, and the signs are already showing up that we are approaching the climb up towards the "plateau of productivity" as Gartner calls it. This is when it starts to be fun.

Nicely said,
Esteban
.-= Esteban Kolsky´s last blog ..Things I Dont Want to Hear Anymore in 2010 =-.

Twitter Comment

love this quote "Its this focus on media rather than social that could doom this industry eventually" from @jaybaer [link to post]

- Posted using Chat Catcher

Jay ... as usual the information that you provide is very useful. As a social media consultant who's clients are mostly B2B, any articles or stats that show how important it is to use social media , I bookmark and show to them. In order for the businesses I work with to understand "why" they should be using social media, it is very important for me to show them information from other sources. Rather then me just telling them how valuable it is , I need to convince them that they need to utilize this type of marketing from other experts in the field so .... thank you !
melanie

Your assessments are spot on. You're exactly right about focusing more on the social than the media. I just found your blog today and am hooked. I'll be back many times over.

Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media - http://bit.ly/7bLWM2

Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media | Social Media Marketing | Social Media Consulting - Convince & Convert http://is.gd/efBjz

Social media success in world the of business-to-business marketing. Advice from @jaybaer http://ping.fm/1LOdz

RT @robbyslaughter ... @carmencitarae wants to know how B2B service companies can succeed with twitter -/ /- http://bit.ly/bZQlAy

Always good - RT @jaybaer: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/oZoq

Always good - RT @jaybaer: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/oZoq

Yes, I can. In some B2B situations the customer is entirely distanced from the seller, and buying intervals may be 10 years or more.

How do you propose to draw in a consumer, who has little interest in your company and buys so rarely that he or she is likely to have forgotten you ever existed?

Having said that, I think it's definitely possible. But Social Media strategies should not be standalone campaigns. They need to be integrated into what else a company is doing in their Branding/Marketing strategy.

RT @jaybaer: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/oZoq

RT @jaybaer: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/oZoq

@jaybaer says "the goal of social media is to make big companies act like small ones." http://fb.me/CuOUt2KF

RT @jaybaer: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/dVFV

Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media - http://bit.ly/aUEzdY

Fair point. Thanks for the comment. The blog is written for both, as most of my customers are marketers themselves.

RT @jaybaer: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/oZoq

This is great info. Is this blog for other marketers or for your customers? Because if I were a customer, I'd be lost by now. I was taught to always write on a middle school average (when I wrote for a newspaper). I'm not criticizing, because I see that you're very intelligent and knowledgeable about the subject matter; I just fear that people may get lost in the detail.

I admire your ability.

RT @jaybaer - Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/oZoq

RT @jaybaer Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/oZoq

RT @jaybaer: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media http://om.ly/dVFV

Don't think u can find success with #socialmedia at a B2B company? Think again. http://bit.ly/cbKzRp

RT @jaybaer: Crushing Myth of B2B Soc Med http://om.ly/oLmG << ppl r scared of B2B SM bc benefits are not as immedietly aparent. great post!

Trackbacks

  1. [...] more here: Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media | | Social Media Consulting … Share and [...]

  2. [...] An interesting post today. Here’s a quick excerpt: Are there differences between B2B and B2C in social media? Of course. But those differences are at the tactics layer, not the strategy layer. Creating and calibrating a social media strategy for any company should follow the same … Read the rest of this great post Here [...]

  3. [...] Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media | | Social Media Consulting – Convince & Convert – “But all this social media stuff doesn’t apply to B2B right? – socialmedia b2b marketing social media [...]

  4. [...] “Crushing the Myth of B2B Social Media” Jay Baer writes: Yes, social media applies to B2B. In fact, social media can be MORE transformative [...]

  5. [...] case for B2B social media has been well documented over the past few months (here, here, and here to cite just a few), but one of the most important components a business must [...]

  6. [...] winning campaigns, measure ROI, and reach audiences. Jay Baer offers an interesting analysis at Convince and Convert. More of my thoughts on the subject of B2B and B2C social media are shared in my post, “The [...]